Case
Student can read but not comprehend

The teacher has a student who can read every word in the book. He also can comprehends some of the story but doesn't understand the deeper meaning behind the story. The teacher has tried to go page by page with the student but sometimes he still doesn't understand. The teacher believes the student may not understand some of the story because of experience and lack of vocabulary. Where should she start to problem solve to help the student?

Solution #1
Top Solution
When working with ELL students, I preview the book before we read it and select vocabulary words that I know the student might struggle with. I add a picture and definition for the word in the vocabulary notebook and we review these before we read so that comprehension is not impeded because of the vocabulary. Also, modeling summarization every few paragraphs or pages (depending on the reading level) can help the student learn how to think about what he or she is reading while reading.

Pre-teaching vocabulary is an essential strategy to assist learners who struggle with comprehension.

good idea

I love the idea of using the passage for vocabulary words and modeling summarizing.

Solution #2
The teacher may want to start by giving the student informational text such as articles, and teach them how to apply close reading strategies. She can also use guided reading to help the student focus on identifying and recalling specific information within the text that the teacher has targeted. These two strategies will address vocabulary and help the student to get a deeper understanding of the text.

I would exactly do this

This is a great solution. I think guided reading is a great idea.

Solution #3
I think a good strategy to help with comprehension is starting off a new book, or subject by doing a book walk, or chapter walk. Have the student go through the story or chapter, looking at the pictures or vocabulary words, and have them discuss what they think it may be about before starting the book, chapter or lesson.
Solution #4
In utilizing a word bank and dictionary, you could create an experience that intrinsically motivates the student to use different words that they understand, and have the student pursue different words that they think are "cool".
Solution #5
I would make sure the child has received or is receiving ESOL services to truly help in this area.
Solution #6
Maybe asking the student to recall what the story was about and see if he can recall details such as items in the story.

good idea