When a parent continually asks for the teacher's opinion on whether their child has ADHD or not, what is the appropriate response since we are not doctors? We can describe the behaviors we see in the classroom, but where do we draw the line?
Solution #1
Top Solution
ysaZan
Joined on Oct 2015
76 points
Intermediate
The teacher should be honest with parents, saying that he/she is not a medical expert. Teachers may certainly say something such as "Johnny is having difficulty staying on task" or "I had to redirect Johnny three times today because he was not on task." However, it is inappropriate for teachers to make a medical diagnosis. Teachers should refer parents to the child's doctor, and teachers may refer parents to guidance for more information.
Solution #2
eryMav
Joined on Oct 2015
75 points
Intermediate
Under no circumstance would I insinuate that the child has ADHD but I would describe the student's behavior and actions in the classroom. I would then refer the parent to a school counselor or school psychologist as they will be more equipped to handle this situation and can point the parent in the right direction.
Solution #3
qyQaGy
Joined on Oct 2015
78 points
Intermediate
I think you are right to tell the parent that you are not a doctor and cannot make a diagnosis. Keep parents informed on the behavior that you see and tell them that if they are concerned they can have their child seen by a doctor. I feel that too many children are mis-diagnosed with ADHD because children and their energy and interests are misunderstood.
Solution #4
qyryMa
Joined on Oct 2014
203 points
Expert
I would explain to the parent that you are not a doctor so you can only give them things you have observed with the student and then let them know they might want to bring those things up when they see a Doctor.
Solution #5
utyDaW
Joined on Oct 2020
200 points
Expert
Teachers cannot diagnose a child it is the doctors responsibility to do so. What the teacher can do, is share what he or she has observed during the day and recommend that the child should see a doctor and get it checked out.
Solution #6
jyteXa
Joined on Oct 2015
105 points
Advanced
Really, all you can say is what you are saying. We are definitely not doctors. Now, I know that sometimes it is very clear to us that a child probably has ADHD. However, we could never tell the parent that. You simply tell their symptoms and what you notice in the classroom. When they ask for advice all we can really tell them is to consult a doctor.
Solution #7
ZaBuBy
Joined on Oct 2016
200 points
Expert
You are not allowed to diagnose a child.
Solution #8
juWuPe
Joined on Jul 2016
203 points
Expert
Advise the parent that they should take the student to get a professional evaluation.
New Solution
Solution Submitted Successfully
Thank you for submitting your solution. Your contribution is greatly appreciated!
Rate the Solution
Vote Submitted
Thank you for rating the solution and congratulations, you have just earned 1 point for rating.